German civil society calls for a definitive end to telecom data retention

27. 4. 2010 | 12:48

More than 40 organisations and associations have sent a letter asking the German Federal Minister of Justice to "push for the abolition of EU telecommunications data retention requirements" which compel phone and Internet companies to collect data about their customers' communications. According to the letter, data retention puts confidential activity and contacts (for example journalists, crisis lines and business partners) at
risk of disclosure by way of data leaks and abuses. It is expensive and damages the freedom of communication.

Among the 48 signatories of the letter there are German civil liberties, data protection and human rights associations as well as crisis line and emergency call operators, professional associations of journalists, jurists and doctors, major trade unions, the Federation of German Consumer Organisations and the eco Association of the German Internet Industry.

On 2 March 2010, the German Federal Constitutional Court ruled the German data retention provisions unconstitutional and void, following complaints from over 34 000 German citizens. However, a 2006 EU directive compels member states to implement a data retention regime. The European Commission is currently reviewing this directive. The German Federal Minister of
Justice, a member of the liberal party, has yet to call for an end to the EU-wide compulsion to collect communications data.

"The EU-wide requirement to retain the entire population's communications data, introduced in 2005, is outdated", comments Patrick Breyer of the German Working Group on Data Retention. "Blanket data retention has proven to be superfluous, harmful and unconstitutional in many states across Europe, such as Germany, Austria, Belgium, Greece, Romania and Sweden. These states prosecute crime just as effectively using targeted instruments, such as the internationally agreed Convention on Cybercrime. Where data retention has been implemented, the crime clearance rate has not increased. For example in North Rhine-Westphalia, the most populated state of Germany, 85% of all reported Internet crime was cleared in 2007 before the introduction of data retention legislation, but only 77% was cleared in 2008 and in 2009 after the implementation of data retention. The EU regulations must now be made more flexible to allow for alternative procedures that work more intelligently than an untargeted stockpiling of data."

"About 70% of all Germans are opposed to a recording of their contacts and location in the absence of any suspicion", says Florian Altherr of the Working Group. "They want to be sure that their private and business contacts to marital crisis lines, lawyers, journalists and others cannot fall into the wrong hands or erroneously make them a suspect in the eyes of
law enforcement authorities. The countless number of data scandals such as the systematic abuse of communications data at Deutsche Telekom have taught us that only erased data is safe data."

Translation of the letter to the Federal Minister of Justice (19.04.2010),en/

The German Federal Constitutional Court's judgement on data retention

The Commission's draft evaluation report

Position of the German government (only in German, 30.09.2009)

Response by the German Working Group on Data retention (13.11.2009)

Crime clearance rate in 2009 (only in German)

Poll on data retention (only in German, 25.01.2010)

(Press release of the German Working Group on Data Retention)

Ke stažení

 Jak funguje internet

 Ochrana OÚ

 CC příručka obálka

 CC samospráva


 CC manuál pro města a obce

Kdo jsme

  • Tento web provozuje iure, neziskovka zabývající se ochranou občanských svobod.

Logo IuRe


Support us